Asphalt shingles have been the most commonly used roofing materials for decades. However, metal roofing has gained widespread popularity in recent years. Still, many homeowners are unaware of the benefits of metal roofing. So, it can often be difficult for people to determine which roofing material is right for them. The following guide provides you with valuable insights so that you can make the right choice between the two.
Asphalt Shingles
Asphalt shingles are made of asphalt granules, fiberglass, and tar. There are three types of asphalt shingles, with the architectural types being the most commonly used ones.
Use-Case Scenarios for Asphalt Shingles
You should consider using them for your home in the following use-case scenarios:
A Budget-Friendly Roofing Option
Asphalt shingle roofs are more affordable to install as compared to their metal counterparts. These roofing materials help you create the ideal combination of reliable weather protection and aesthetics without the need to pay a premium price. If you will be moving in or selling the house over the next decade, such a roof can provide great value.
Perfect for Standard Roof Designs
Standard gable roofs and single-slope roofs are considered normal roof designs. If you have a standard roof design, you can easily choose asphalt shingles. This is because they are much simpler to install on such uncomplicated structures. Both the installation times and labor costs stay low with this material.
Reasons for Considering Asphalt Shingles
The main reasons you should choose asphalt shingles for your roof are as follows:
1. Readily Available & Affordable
Asphalt shingles are not only easily available everywhere but are also the most affordable roofing shingles. If you want your roofing project to be completed quickly, these materials can be easily and promptly procured.
2. Versatile Styles
As mentioned above, asphalt shingles are available in three different forms. These include:
- 3-Tab shingles
- Luxury shingles
- Dimensional shingles
The 3-tab shingles are the simplest and appear flat on the roof. While these were traditionally the most popular, they are now replaced by their dimensional counterparts.
Dimensional or architectural shingle roofs look somewhat similar to slate roofs and they offer greater depth and dimension. You can find a greater number of aesthetic options with luxury shingles. Besides, they are available in various shingle shapes and provide a layered look.
3. Exceptional Protection
Asphalt shingles have come a long way in providing better protection. Modern shingles offer:
- Excellent protection against streaks created by algae
- Class A fire protection rating
- Strong adhesive qualities to prevent wind from lifting the shingles
Metal Roofing
Asphalt shingles may be slightly more affordable to install, metal roofing generally offers better ROI over the long term. The latter’s cost-effectiveness mostly comes from its greater durability.
Use-Case Scenarios for Metal Roofing
Some of the main use-case scenarios for metal roofing are as follows:
Extreme Weather Conditions
If you live in an area that experiences extreme weather more often, you should consider metal roofing. Metal roofs can provide better protection against:
- Extreme heat
- Storms
- High winds
- Hail
- Wildfires
Long-Term Investment
A metal roof, when well maintained, can last you a lifetime or longer. If you plan on living in your home for a long time, you should consider metal roofing. Metal roofs are exceptionally durable, last long, and don’t require frequent repairs.
Reasons for Considering Metal Roofs
The different reasons for considering metal roofing for your home are as follows:
1. Fire-Resistant Roofing
Metal is a non-combustible material. When you choose metal roofing for your home, you will be installing a roof with a Class-4 fire rating, the highest possible rating.
2. Protection from the Elements
You can choose specially designed metal roofing designed to withstand hurricanes and tornadoes. Additionally, these roofs are resistant to rusting and oxidation. They can also go through constant cycles of freeze and thaw without getting damaged.
3. Lightweight Roofing
If you live in a region prone to earthquakes, heavy snow, or high winds, it is recommended not to have a top-heavy roof. Metal works as an exceptionally lightweight material option for roofs. This further means that your roof will not require a strong support structure to hold the additional weight.
So, now you know the different reasons for considering these two different roofing materials. While the cost of installing asphalt shingles is lower, a metal roof can more than repay its initial costs over its lifespan. It is recommended to discuss your unique needs and preferences with your roofing company before making the right decision.